|

Why You Should Rent for a Year Before Buying in a Small Resort Town

Why You Should Rent for a Year Before Buying in a Small Resort Town

People relocating to a metro can buy on arrival. The comps are dense, the data is public, and if you pick the wrong neighborhood, you are fifteen minutes from a better one.

Small resort markets do not work that way. I sell real estate in Moore County, North Carolina, a golf market of seven towns that produced about 6,000 residential sales over the past two years. I tell most out-of-state buyers to lease for a year first, which costs me commissions. Here is what that year gets them.

Town lines cost more than the map suggests

Moore County’s 2026 county rate is $0.2900 per $100 of assessed value, plus $0.0425 for advanced life support. Each town adds its own. The Village of Pinehurst adds $0.2200 for a combined $0.5525. Southern Pines comes to $0.6225. Whispering Pines $0.7325. Aberdeen $0.7525. Carthage $0.8375. Property outside any municipality pays the county rate plus a $0.0875 fire district levy, for $0.4200.

Those towns are inside a twenty-minute drive of each other. On a $500,000 house, the spread between the cheapest and most expensive municipal option here is about $2,100 a year, every year. Search Pinehurst real estate and the results will span three or four tax jurisdictions without telling you which is which. A rental search does the same thing. The tax office does not.

Days on market swing wildly by segment

In Aberdeen, the Woodgreen subdivision recorded 12 sales over 24 months at a $290,000 median, with a median of 22 days on market. In Pinehurst, Dogwood Terrace recorded 5 sales at a $369,500 median with a median of 220 days. Both are in Moore County. Both are ordinary residential inventory.

The sample sizes are small, which is itself the point. In a market this size, a subdivision may produce four or five sales in two years, and the difference between a three-week sale and a seven-month sale is not visible until you are the one holding it. A renter watching listings for twelve months learns which segment they are shopping before they own something in it.

Seasonality is real and it is not the season you expect

Long-term rental supply in a resort market competes with short-term rental demand. When a major event comes to town, inventory that would otherwise go on a twelve-month lease goes to the event week instead, at a multiple of the monthly rate. Pinehurst hosts the U.S. Open in 2029, 2035, 2041 and 2047 under the USGA’s anchor site agreement, and the men’s and women’s championships run back-to-back in 2029.

If you are searching for a lease, availability and pricing in a resort town move on a local calendar rather than a national one. Ask a local property manager when their inventory turns over before you assume the listings you see in February are the listings you will see in May.

The things a listing portal cannot tell you

Some of the MLS data underneath the public portals is wrong in ways that matter. Association fee fields in this county are a good example: some listings record a monthly dues figure in the annual field, which makes a $200-a-month HOA look like $200 a year. In one subdivision here, Knollwood Village, that reporting error is confirmed. In several others, what looks like the same error is a genuine split between condo and single-family dues inside one subdivision name.

Club memberships are another. In parts of Pinehurst, a property may carry a transferable country club membership, which is a separate asset from the house and is not reliably disclosed in listing data.

A year of living here surfaces this. Twelve weekends of house-hunting trips does not.

What to do with the lease year

Drive the commute you will actually drive, in the season you will drive it. Sit in the neighborhood on a weekday evening. Ask what your tax bill would be at the town line, not the county line. Track three or four subdivisions you like and watch how long their listings sit.

Then buy. Most of the people I have worked with who did it this way ended up in a different town than the one they named on the first phone call.

 

Comments are closed.

↑